top of page
Hot Tomato BackPaio

Our Pizza Style

​A little bit about us; we are an East coast style pizzeria. That means we bake on a traditional stone deck oven and use ingredients consistent with old-school New York and New Jersey pizzerias.

We make all of the dough in-house, daily, cook all of our meats, make our sauces and prep all of our vegetables daily as well. We source locally raised sausage and bacon and use local produce growers during the growing season. 

All of this might make you think we are a fancy establishment, but don't you worry! We still like to keep it real. We are a little rough around the edges and ok with it; we don't have wait staff, and yes the line can get long because of it. It gets crowded in here, and noisy, and sometimes we crank the music up too loud. You'll get your slice served on a paper plate, just like 'back home' (if you are an East coaster that is...) and since we in an old building with crooked floors, some of our tables don't sit perfectly flush, so watch your beers! All that being said though, what we can promise you is that we do our best, every day, to bring you the best pizza we can make, using the freshest ingredients available to us, all in an attempt to bring a little slice of Love to our awesome little town.

The Hot Tomato was founded by Jen Zeuner and Anne Keller, former cycling industry peeps who decided that Fruita needed a few more eateries than it had back in 2005. Jen and Anne have now been in Fruita since 2002, and the Tomato has been open since 2005.

bottom of page